| Year | Winner | Points | Runner-Up | Points | Played at |
| 2005 | Cawder | 9.5 | Kingsknowe | 8.5 | Cawder / Kingsknowe |
| 2006 | Duddingston | 10 | Whitecraigs | 8 | Duddingston / Whitecraigs |
| 2007 | Dalmahoy | 9.5 | Windyhill | 8.5 | Windyhill / Dalmahoy |
| 2008 | Royal Burgess | 12 | Fereneze | 6 | Fereneze / Royal Burgess |
| 2009 | Cathkin Braes | 11.5 | Royal Burgess | 6.5 | Cathkin Braes / Royal Burgess |
| 2010 | Royal Burgess | 13.5 | Bishopbriggs | 4.5 | Bishopbriggs / Royal Burgess |
| 2011 | Royal Burgess, 1st Extra Hole | 9 | Bishopbriggs | 9 | Bishopbriggs / Royal Burgess |
| 2012 | Sandyhills | 9.5 | Royal Burgess | 8.5 | Royal Burgess / Sandyhills |
| 2013 | Royal Burgess | 6.5 | Haggs Castle | 2.5 | Cowglen |
| 2014 | Cawder | 6.5 | Bruntsfield | 2.5 | Royal Burgess |
| 2015 | Cawder | 5.5 | Royal Burgess | 3.5 | Balmore |
| 2016 | Cawder | 5 | Turnhouse | 4 | Bruntsfield Links |
| 2017 | Mortonhall | 6 | Cawder | 3 | Balmore |
| 2018 | Cathkin Braes | 6 | Turnhouse | 3 | Musselburgh |
| 2019 | Mortonhall | 6 | Haggs Castle | 3 | Pollok |
| 2020 | Not Held | ||||
| 2021 | Duddingston | 6 | Glasgow | 3 | Hilton Park |
| 2022 | Duddingston | 5.5 | Glasgow | 3.5 | Turnhouse Golf Club |